BUY THEM BOTH
Since Murphy's Law dictates I will be making a repeat trip to the parts store, I buy both and return the wrong one at my convience. Suits me much better than putting the old one back on

so I can rush back to the parts store before they close to get the proper one. It is two trips reguardless but much less hassle to buy both initially and KNOW I have the right part when I begin the job.
I admit this does not work if there are more than two choices or if the store has to order a part or buying on line.