JamesDowning wrote:If you're just installing a new carrier, you should have it re-shimmed. There are machining tolerances between the bearings and the ring gear that differ between parts. Installing a new one should prove to be very close to correct, but if you want the diff to be robust, you should at least check the tooth contact pattern.
It is not just that you "should" have it re-shimmed, you MUST have it re-set-up or the gears will likely dynamite!
The cost of setting up gears if you are not equipped to do so yourself far exceeds replacing the entire axle assembly.
If replacement of the entire axle is possible, go that route.
Same up front. If you can find a 4.10 carrier, go that route and swap out everything instead of trying to install new gears. Many shops will charge between $250 - 500 to set up one axle. It is a time consuming process.
If 35" tires are in your future, even 4.56 is a tad low. We run 4.56 with 33s in most of our builds and those gears are not in any way too steep for 33" tires. I don't believe that a 4.56 gearset is available for the front axle, however.
With 3.42 gears and 35" tires, you will never again see OD except at freeway speeds of over 70. If you can live with that okay, but most people can't. Your crawl ratio will also suck. You won't be able to slow down enough on trails that require 35" tires. If you are just running on the street, you may (may!) get away with it, but your truck will be a slug that passes everything except a gas station.
My worst tire/gear ratio setup was 3.73 gears with 38" tires. The truck was setup for sand/mud and I wanted to be able to spin the tires fast in low range. I could hit 85 @ 6000 rpm in low range and had 550 hp big block pushing me. Truck was fast and mean, but barely drivable in high range. It idled at 55.